Weinstein Co. appealing 'Blue Valentine' NC-17 rating

A week after the MPAA branded its domestic drama Blue Valentine with an NC-17 rating, the Weinstein Company has decided to appeal the decision and hope for an R without any trims to the film. “We respect the work of the MPAA,” Harvey Weinstein says in a statement today, “and we hope, after having a chance to sit down with them, they will see that our appeal is reasonable, and the film, which is an honest and personal portrait of a relationship, would be significantly harmed by such a rating.” Weinstein is right: The NC-17 would limit the film’s audience and its Oscar chances. The question is whether the notoriously stubborn MPAA will budge. Blue Valentine, starring Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams, has its U.K. premiere tomorrow night at the London Film Festival and hits U.S. theaters on Dec. 31.


Comments (22 total) Add your comment
  • keith

    Hmm. I hope they are successful. I’m not terribly optimistic, given the MPAA’s record. But the Weinsteins could spin this whole battle into a solid oscar campaign. I guess? I don’t know. A part of me thinks they should make a few trims so the film will get scene and can participate, rightfully, in the awards season. But I hate the thought of them making changes, particularly when they are unnecessary. It’s a no win situation.

    • Ibad

      I agree that Weinstein could use it to his advantage to get the film press attention, especially attention to the fact that everyone knows it’s not worthy of an NC-17 rating.

      But that’s a gamble, and he should definitely try to get it appealed first. If that doesn’t happen, then I would hope he doesn’t convince Cianfrance to edit (I like how Cianfrance and Hooper both have the conviction to refuse to edit their films to get a lower rating this year).

  • RJ

    If the movie is so good then it shouldn’t hurt it one bit to remove some nudity or foul language. Just because its a film about a relationship doesn’t mean you have to show them being intimate in gory detail. That’s what the porn industry is for.

    • K

      Your assuming they’re are being intimate in gory detail. That may not be the case. MPAA gives out NC-17 ratings not just because of sex scenes. If that’s the case then Monster’s Ball would have been an NC-17 rating.

    • Allan EekHart

      Actually there isn’t much “nudity or foul language”. That is why this NC-17 rating was so surprising!

    • davey

      I saw the film at TIFF and there is NOTHING in this film that is NC-17 worthy. What the hell is wrong with America and the MPAA when a movie like Saw 7 is Rated R and Blue Valentine is rated NC-17!

      • alex21

        can you tell us what it could possibly be that they’re basing the NC 17 on? is it violence? i’m curious..

      • Esther Greenwood

        I read on another blog that the scene that earned the movie the rating depicted Gosling’s character having sex with his wife even though she didn’t really want to. Not a rape situation but one where she consented but just wasn’t into it and looked miserable as it was happening. I don’t think that’s enough to warrant an NC-17 rating; to me, it would show how much their relationship had disintegrated (I’m assuming; I haven’t seen it).

    • Lisa Simpson

      “Intimate in gory detail”? It’s a relationship movie, with includes moments of sexual intimacy, not a slasher/sex flick.

      • Amy

        is that the actual statement? could it maybe be a forced intimate situation?

    • UncleWalty

      why should they have to tailor to the film to suit your sensibilities? If you don’t like sex or nudity or gore or violence, then don’t watch it.

    • RyanK

      Some “nudity or foul language” is not a reason why the producers of a film would appeal an NC-17 rating. Things like that can be taken out easily enough. One of the problems with the rating system is that it often has less to do with nudity, and more to do with how sex is portrayed or acted, which yes, can be very important to the movie. I shouldn’t go into detail on a public board, but for those curious, I would highly recommend watching “This Film is Not Yet Rated”

      • George

        have you even seen the movie? come on, be honest.

  • What’s Good for the Gander…

    Yeah, but if we get to see Ryan Gosling completely naked, then keep it NC-17 and I’ll be the first in line!

    • Katie

      Yeah, but we don’t get to see him naked, so it’s a lose lose.

  • Sarah

    Wasn’t Midnight Cowboy rated NC-17? It did pretty well at the Oscars, if I’m not mistaken.

    • K

      NC-17 was much different back then. And they changed the rating of Midnight Cowboy to an R rating a few years later.

      • Troy

        Actually, Midnight Cowboy was rated X. X was originally an MPAA rating before being co-opted by the Adult Industry. NC-17 was not introduced until 1990; it replaced the X rating on the MPAA scale at that point.

  • ChrisV

    I too am really perplexed at what scene was so graphic that this movie got an NC-17 rating. I’m sure the movie would be trimmed somehow to get an ‘R’ rating rather than release it, as is, and not have it shown in theaters nationwide. Hopefully, the movie gets the revised rating so no editing takes place.

  • Daisy

    What I think they should do is re-submit the film with no edits at all and see what happens. I think that Trey Parker and Matt Stone said in This Film Is Not Yet Rated, that they did something similar with South Park: Bigger, Longer, and Uncut–they did not alter the scenes that the MPAA told them to and then added more violent and bloody war scenes just to see what would happen. The MPAA is a complete joke and they often slap an NC-17 rating for sex and not for violence. No slasher film in recent memory (if ever) has gotten an NC-17 rating, which is completely ridiculous. BTW If you have not yet seen This Film Is Not Yet Rated, you should check it out–the ridiculousness and utter hypocrisy of the MPAA is highlighted. I hope the appeal works as this film is high on my must-see list and I would prefer to see it in its original form and not edited for the MPAA.

    • m1

      Didn’t This Film Is Not Yet Rated get an NC-17, too?

  • Affiliate MasterClass

    I love your post review, it makes me to produce my experience on my small blog. I we do hope you improve your review, I’ll follow your update. See you on the next.

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in Movies


Latest News

Most Commented

PopWatch | Entertainment Weekly's EW.com



Snapchat's getting its own web series, and it's called 'Literally Can't Even'

Comments +

Sending self-destructing pictures and videos is nice and all, but Snapchat wants to do more. The popular social network is broadening its horizons and getting into the entertainment game—by making an original web series named after a rather tired Internet meme. 

Read Full Story

'Disney Infinity 2.0' Toy Box comes to iPhones, iPads

Comments +

Disney Interactive has released the Disney Infinity: Toy Box 2.0 for free on iPhones and iPads, meaning it’s now possible for you to have Aladdin and Baymax race each other in Guardians of the Galaxy-themed cars when you’re on the go. 

Read Full Story

How 'Parenthood' thrived, despite a spoiler-addicted society

Comments +

In the age of live-tweeting, the most talked-about shows on television tend to be those that give viewers (and Twitter users) plenty of big, bold moments that inspire strong, immediate reactions. Which, in turn, means that the most talked-about shows inevitably end up being labeled TV’s most successful shows. Think about it: There’s Game of Thrones, with its Red Wedding, Purple Wedding, and continuous stream of unexpected deaths. We have Shonda Rhimes, who’s arguably the queen of the WTF moment with ScandalGrey’s Anatomy, and How to Get Away With Murder. And then there’s the ever-more-popular True Detective format, which is built entirely around solving a mystery—preferably one with a surprising result. Essentially, TV’s best dramas must, on some level, be edge-of-your-seat thrillers.

That is, unless they’ve got the Bravermans.

Read Full Story

Conan O'Brien, Marshawn Lynch, and Rob Gronkowski lose their minds over 'Mortal Kombat'

Comments +

For a special Super Bowl edition of Conan O’Brien’s very funny Clueless Gamer segments, the late-night host convinced Marshawn Lynch of the Seattle Seahawks and Rob Gronkowski of the New England Patriots to face each other for a few matches of the yet-to-be-released Mortal Kombat X

Read Full Story

'Transistor,' 'Rogue Legacy' among free games for PlayStation Plus in February

Comments +

Sony is refreshing the free games available as part of PlayStation Plus next week, and the new selection will include one of 2014’s most memorable games and a brand new title.

Read Full Story

PopWatch Confessional: The thing you used to love (that now makes you cringe)

Comments +

Ahh, youth, when naivete and limitless free time conspire to form overwhelming cultural obsessions—the sort that burn bright and hot, consuming vast amounts of energy until you get a little older and realize, “Wait. What the hell was I thinking?” (This is the moment where I pause, look to the heavens, and thank whatever’s up there that I never ended up getting a Rent-inspired tattoo when I was 18.)

Which brings me to this week’s PopWatch confessional: What’s the movie/TV show/musical act/AIDS-themed rock operetta (ahem) that you were once obsessed with—to a degree that makes your present-day self want to laugh and cry simultaneously? The EW staff’s answers may surprise you. (Yeah, they probably won’t.)

Read Full Story

Chris Hardwick looks back at five years of Nerdist podcast

Comments +

Five years in, Chris Hardwick’s Nerdist podcast is only continuing to grow.

What started as three friends gathering around some microphones on Super Bowl Sunday in 2010 has turned into over 600 episodes of the flagship Nerdist podcasts, a website, and a host of other podcasts on the Nerdist Network. 

The show celebrates its fifth anniversary with episode 631, a special live show recorded at the NerdMelt Showroom. Hardwick spoke to EW about the live show, what Nerdist has meant for him over the last five years, and where he hopes to take it in the years to come.

Read Full Story

Warner Bros. to launch new Batman, Justice League animated movies based on toys

Comments +

Chances are you’ve already gotten a sneak peek at DC’s next big animated project if you’ve spent any time buying superhero toys.

Read Full Story

'Life Is Strange' Episode 1 review: 'Chrysalis'

Comments +
Life Is Strange

High school can be a daily exercise in embarrassing encounters. Stumbling through an awkward exchange with your current crush, taking a volleyball straight to the face during gym, having a teacher ask you a question while you’re daydreaming—wouldn’t it be great to rewind time and prevent these horrific moments from ever happening?

Life Is Strange allows its main character, Max Caulfield, to do just that. The episodic series from Dontnod Entertainment and Square Enix capitalizes on the collective trials of navigating teenage life. The first episode, “Chrysalis,” is not without its issues —some hokey dialogue and stilted line reading can make the centerpiece of the game, the characters, a bit unbelievable. But it also sets the stage for a relatable tale with a nice sci-fi spin and enough hanging plot threads to encourage sticking around for future episodes.

Read Full Story

The Super Bowl ads of 2015: Watch them here

Comments +
Mindy Kaling 02

Come Sunday evening, the commercials with the biggest stars, cutest animals, and best jokes might be more important than who actually wins Super Bowl XLIX. (Budweiser’s lost puppy commercial vs. Patriots/Seahawks? Our money is on the puppy.)

Read Full Story

More from Our Partners

From Our Partners

TV Recaps

TV Recaps | Entertainment Weekly's EW.com

TV Recaps

More from Our Partners

Powered by WordPress.com VIP