Cannes: 'Carlos' is a gripping portrait of the mind of a terrorist. But did it have to be five hours long?

carlosThe prospect of sitting through a very long movie can be intimidating (if it’s a dud, you aren’t just bored, you’re trapped). But from the moment I heard about Carlos, Olivier Assayas’ five-hour-and-33-minute dramatization of the life of Carlos the Jackal (née Ilich Ramirez Sanchez), the notorious, Venezualan-born radical-Marxist terrorist mercenary of the ’70s and ’80s, I was salivating to see it. It sounded like a real down-and-dirty, meat-and-potatoes movie, the sort of thing that can be cathartically satisfying after sitting through a week’s worth of festival-friendly art films. And, in fact, Carlos turns out to be a rivetingly journalistic blow-by-blow, murder-by-murder account of a scoundrel’s rise and fall. Staged in a convulsive, hand-held procedural style that suggests a fusion of Munich and Dog Day Afternoon and The Godfather, the film was made for French television, but it’s every inch a movie. That said, I can’t agree with the festival watchers — like indieWIRE‘s Todd McCarthy — who hailed Carlos as the second coming. Yes, the movie is enthralling compared to Che, the last Cannes epic about a legendary gun-toting Marxist-Leninist. But the truth is that Carlos, after about the midway point, slowly begins to run out of gas. The movie doesn’t get deeper, it just gets longer.

It seems obvious to me that Assayas, the talented and ferociously eclectic French maverick (Summer Hours, Boarding Gate, Irma Vep), was out to craft an exploration of the heart and mind of a terrorist that could speak to audiences in the al-Qaeda age. Carlos the Jackal predated the present wave of terrorism, but he was a spiritual precursor to it. He cast himself as a blood brother to the Palestinian movement, and his link-up of righteous “revolution” and homicide marked him as a bridge between the anti-establishment terrorists who sprung up like weeds in the ’60s and early ’70s (the Baader-Meinhoff Group, the Symbionese Liberation Army, the Weathermen) and the anti-Western, bring-it-all-down zeal of Osama bin Laden.

The Carlos we see shares aspects with every one of those figures, and with Che Guevara too; he’s like Che reborn as a machine-gun-toting hijacker. The 33-year-old Venezualan actor Edgar Ramirez, in a rawly charismatic, screen-grabbing performance, plays Carlos as a strutting mass of contradictions. Ramirez, an actor I wasn’t familiar with, bears a striking resemblance to the young Val Kilmer, with a touch of Mark Ruffalo’s puppy-eyed pensive reserve. He doesn’t look like a murderous fanatic, but that’s just what Carlos is.

He’s the kind of man who can wander, without a tremor of anxiety, into a bank, take everyone there hostage, and shoot several of them dead as though he were swatting mosquitoes. His connection to his cause is ruthless, total, and extreme. But is he acting out of ideals or out of allegiance to his own swagger?

Hiring himself out, in 1973, to the PFLP (the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine), Carlos views himself as a “soldier,” pure and simple — a stoic lone warrior in the struggle between imperialism and justice. That, in his view, is why he’s able to kill without mercy. But he’s also a romantic Marxist who throws off the guilty burden of his bourgeois past by transforming himself into a glamorous sociopath who can kill like a machine. He kills to fulfill an idea of potency about himself.

A baby-faced Latin American macho, Carlos gets off on his personal power, luring one woman after another into his orbit and, between slugs of Johnny Walker Red, treating them like harlots and whores. He becomes a celebrity, the media’s favorite Violent Rebel With a Cause, and he thinks it’s his divine right to sleep around. But the most dubious partners he climbs into bed with aren’t sexual, they’re political. To finance his operations, he allies himself with the sleaziest of Middle Eastern dictators — Muammar Qaddafi, the newly installed Iraqi president Saddam Hussein — and he creates a base of operations in any Communist-bloc police state that will have him. To Carlos, a place like East Germany is “socialist” and therefore upstanding according to his rigid “freedom fighter” logic. In other words, he’s a parasite who feeds off the corrupt power of pathological regimes; he can’t see that these regimes have no idealism at all, and that they’re using him. Yet the risks Carlos takes are real, and the way that Ramirez plays him, so is his half-mad, movie-cool fearlessness.

Part I of Carlos is a hypnotic succession of kidnappings, hair-trigger showdowns, implosive leftist strategy sessions, and bumblingly impromptu rocket-launcher attacks on taxiing Israeli airliners. It’s all followed, in the first half of Part II, by the movie’s single most dazzling sequence, an amazingly sustained, moment-by-moment re-enactment of Carlos’ most jaw-dropping act of terrorism-for-hire: On December 20, 1975, he busts into the conference of OPEC leaders in Vienna and takes 60 hostages, demanding that a communiqué about the Palestinian cause be read on Austrian TV and radio networks. He asks for, and gets, a DC-9 and flies the hostages to Algiers, then Libya, then back to Algiers again. Ah, the terrorism of the ’70s! How spectacularly clunky in its spotlight-grabbing impotence! As Carlos’ plan starts to fall apart, we see, in this episode, a revolutionary purist beginning to crumple: He’s now revealed as a thug who has passed through the looking glass of his own crackpot idealism. Of course, the “dream” was always just a murderous sham. Here, then, is the theme of Carlos: the hidden narcissism of the media-age terrorist — the egomaniac’s delusions that he conceals (behind a wall of fanaticism) even to himself.

Up until this point, the movie is masterly. But as Carlos gets cut loose, one by one, from his state sponsors, so that he’s now committing his terrorist actions in the name of “the Armed Wing of the Arab Revolution” (which is downright funny, because that’s just a kind of bogus corporate logo for himself), Carlos begins to grow repetitive and a bit monotonous. It looks at Carlos and sees an increasingly frazzled and self-centered series of acts (by the end, he’s even trying liposuction), but there’s no tragedy and no revelation, no intensification of the film’s earlier fascination. For the last two hours, we more or less watch him degenerate into a bloated bum, but Raging Bull this movie is not. What it lacks is Martin Scorsese’s psychological grandeur.

Carlos is being distributed by IFC, and I assume that the full-length version will be available for video-on-demand, and maybe (as Che was) as a “roadshow” event in select theaters. The movie certainly deserves to be seen. But as electrifying as some of it is, I wish that Assayas had made Carlos at once shorter and richer. I wish it were more than an episodic series of galvanizingly staged plots and executions and mishaps. To understand a terrorist, in his very monstrousness, is a valuable thing, but to devote this much time to a terrorist who is mostly an opportunist is wearying.


Comments (12 total) Add your comment
  • Victor Eloy

    I can’t believe EW is actually giving coverage about this person….
    I mean as venezuelan myself I am surprised, Hollywood should appreciate Edgar ramirez acting skills more!……

    I wonder what film will win the Palm D’ ore!!

  • TALLAWAHBOI

    Owen, did your review have to be SIX hours long?

    • Johnny

      Ha, ha i was thinking the same thing. Owen writes so much that the article was puting me to sleep. Lisa can get her point across in half the paragraphs.

      • Ethan

        If you can figure out a Lisa Schwarzbaum point at all…

        He likes to write, I love his writing, and probably won’t see this movie. Keep writing!

  • Elliott

    Now we’ve heard from the ADHD club. I found this a fascinating article. It totally made me want to see the film.

  • george

    The review of the movie was just as long and drawn out as Mr.Gleiberman suggests the movie is aparently they both need an edit.

  • emma

    Don’t you fools get it? Owen is simply trying to justify to his editors the cost of sending him to Cannes for a week and a half at some luxury hotel. Every damn word counts, folks.
    And Lisa is as much of a self-indulgent prose “stylist” as Gleiberman. She may actually be the worse offender.
    I’ve actually had to restrain myself from gagging while reading her blather.

  • Stephen

    I don’t see what’s wrong with long articles like this one. Lots of times, it irritates me when the reviews are too short.

  • Juliet

    I saw this movie (i live in France hehe..) and it was magistral.
    Ok it is not Raging Bull but it is certainly worth to watch maybe even several times to understand the complexity of Carlos the character.
    I didn’t know Edgar Ramirez but now i can tell i am very glad to discover this actor. His performance is dazzling, mind-blowing : a true Star. I hope to see him very soon in other great roles, great movies directed by very talented directors like Assayas.

  • Kwee

    This is a very good post for me. I think you should add more video and pictures because it helps visitors :)

  • juicycouturesale

    Youareamazing! This weblog is so great. I really hope a lot more people read this and get what you are saying, cause let me tell you, its critical stuff. I never would have thought about it this way unless I would run into your web site. Thanks for sharing it. I hope youve excellent achievement.

  • payday loans charlotte

    Thanks for another excellent article. Where else may just anyone get that kind of info in such an ideal manner of writing? I’ve a presentation subsequent week, and I am at the look for such information.

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos in Movies

Advertisement

Latest News

Most Commented

PopWatch | EW.com

Blog

PopWatch

EW's Buffy season 8 deep dive continues: 'No Future for You'/'Wolves at the Gate'

Comments +

EW is diving deep into the Buffyverse for an in-depth look at the beloved TV series’ comic book sequel. In this installment, Joshua Rivera takes a look at issues #6-15, which consist of the “No Future for You” and “Wolves at the Gate” story arcs. There will be Faith. And also some Dracula.

Read Full Story

Blood, Next, Heaven, and more ambiguous film titles that confuse Google

Comments +

Scarface. Psycho. Goodfellas. Some of the most memorable films of all time have taken the one-word title route. But of course, there are film titles that leave movie-goers confused about what exactly they’re in for, like Will Smith’s latest movie, Focus. Is it about a con-artist, an eye doctor appointment, or (plot twist) is it an inspirational Disney sports movie? 

Read Full Story

Looking back on Leonard Nimoy's most interesting non-Trek TV roles

Comments +

Leonard Nimoy had a long and varied television career, appearing in all manner of procedurals, Westerns, and spy shows in an over 60-year career. While many of his post-Star Trek appearances came with a sort of winking nod to his status as a science-fiction icon, the majority of his credits lie elsewhere, in shows every bit as seminal and iconic as Star Trek. Here are a few of the most notable ones. 

Read Full Story

Leonard Nimoy: William Shatner, Patrick Stewart and more remember 'dear friend'

Comments +

Following the news of Leonard Nimoy’s death on Friday, Hollywood quickly reacted to say goodbye to the actor, best known for his role as Spock in the Star Trek franchise. Nimoy was 83, with a career that spanned six decades and allowed him to work with some of Hollywood’s biggest names. 

William ShatnerI loved him like a brother. We will all miss his humor, his talent, and his capacity to love.

Read Full Story

Neil Gaiman, NASA, more remember Leonard Nimoy on Twitter

Comments +

Co-stars, friends, and fans have flocked to Twitter to honor Leonard Nimoy, most remembered for his portrayal of Spock in the Star Trek franchise. Nimoy died at his home in Los Angeles on Friday. He was 83 years old. 

Read Full Story

'The Dress' debate and other misunderstood, iconic dresses

Comments +

Last night and this morning, social media exploded as it failed to definitively answer one simple question: “What colors are this dress?” 

Read Full Story

Chip Zdarsky and Kagan McLeod preview their new sci-fi adventure series, Kaptara -- exclusive

Comments +

Among the many announcements at January’s annual Image Expo, Kaptara—a science fiction series from Chip Zdarsky(Sex Criminals) and Kagan McLeod (Infinite Kung-Fu)—emerged as one of the most interesting. Described by its creators as a “gay Saga,” the new ongoing follows a bioengineer named Keith Kanga, who ends up stranded on the Kaptara… and that means danger for Earth. Can he safely make it home? More importantly, can he figure out how to save his home? As the premise suggests, the comic promises to be a lot more than just a space adventure.

Known primarily for his art, Zdarsky is taking the writer’s seat on this project while collaborating with McLeod, a fellow Toronto illustrator who is making his return to comics. With two crazy Canadians at the helm of their own original story, you can be sure the result will be something epic, exciting, and probably a little off-beat. EW talked to Zdarsky and McLeod about their creative process, how Kaptara came to be, and whether McLeod would really be willing to draw in a reader as a cannibal Smurf. Read on for more, including the reveal of exclusive preview pages from the first issue of Kaptara, in comic stores this April.

Read Full Story

EW recommends: Bieber, baseball, and Broadway

Comments +

Now that we’ve officially made it through the entertainment dry spell that kicks off every new year, EW is looking forward to what 2015 really has to offer. And in order to start your year off right, we’re rounding up our staff picks for what we’re most looking forward to this spring.

Read Full Story

Mortal Kombat X story trailer jumps to the future, introduces a new generation of fighters

Comments +

The Mortal Kombat franchise is primarily famous for its over-the-top and gratuituous gore.

Read Full Story

PopWatch Confessional: What do you watch when you're homesick?

Comments +

Entertainment Weekly staffers live and work in two of the most exciting cities in the world—New York and Los Angeles. But most of us come from somewhere else—and sometimes, especially when the weather is dreary and the entertainment landscape is caught in a post-Oscars/midseason TV premieres, pre-spring blockbusters/TV finales lull, we find ourselves longing for home… and the pop culture that reminds us of the places we’ve left behind. Hence this week’s Confessional question: What do you watch/listen to/read when you’re feeling homesick?

Read Full Story
Page:

More from Our Partners

From Our Partners

TV Recaps

TV Recaps | EW.com

TV Recaps

More from Our Partners

Powered by WordPress.com VIP